• Home
  • Free Marketing Templates
  • Speaker
  • News
  • Events
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Search
Bluewire Media - Web Strategy
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • More
  • Free Workshops & Mini-Trainings
    • Tips for LinkedIn Profile
    • Your Web Marketing Strategy (part 1)
    • Your Web Marketing Strategy (part 2)
    • LinkedIn Accelerator Exec Short Course
    • Build A Marketing Engine
    • 3 Orbits of Marketing
    • 3 Steps To WIn High Value Clients on LinkedIn in 60 Days
    • Calendar Year Planner Guide
    • Weekly Content Planner Guide
    • How to win clients from email marketing
    • Marketing Mini Course – Tools of The Trade
  • Our Best Selling Book
  • Marketing Club
  • Marketing Coaching
    • Free Marketing Scorecard
    • Book 20 Min Growth Plan (free)
    • Coaching Program
  • Corporate Training
    • LinkedIn Marketing – Keynote Speaker & Coach – Adam Franklin
    • Accountants – Social Media Training
    • Financial Adviser – Social Media Training
    • Real Estate – Social Media Training
    • Mortgage Broker – Social Media Training
    • In House LinkedIn Training
    • In House Social Media Training
    • Digital Marketing Training Courses
  • Adam Franklin & Bluewire Media?
    • Meet Adam Franklin
    • 10 Reasons To Work With Us
    • Recognition
    • The Bluewire Story
    • Company Profile

Bluewire Media Web Strategy Blog

Home / Responsive Web Design vs Separate Mobile Site – Which is right for you?

Responsive Web Design vs Separate Mobile Site – Which is right for you?

Posted by Angus Russell

Share5
Share2
Pin
Tweet9
16 Shares

Updated on November 26th, 2019

Bonus: Download the 33 free templates from Web Marketing That Works by Adam Franklin & Toby Jenkins

Responsive Web Design

It’s been obvious for a while now that mobile internet use is on the rise. In fact some estimates suggest that as early as 2013, more people will use mobile devices to access the internet than desktop computers.

It’s equally obvious that if you’re building a website now, you need to think about accommodating mobile users.

Until recently (or to be more precise, until this article by Ethan Marcotte in May 2010), accommodating mobile users meant creating a separate mobile version of your content. While this is fine, it comes with a few disadvantages (which I’ll get to soon).

Over the last year and a half, however, another option has emerged.

Responsive Web Design.

Responsive Web Design

Responsive web design is a relatively new web development technique in which the layout of a website changes according to the size of the screen it is being viewed on. This means that the one website can be optimised for mobiles, tablets and full-sized monitors (and whatever else might be coming in the near future).

On top of that, responsive websites are pretty cool. Check out these examples by following the links then slowly resizing your browser window and watching the elements shuffle around.

  • Robot or Not – Ethan Marcotte’s original example
  • The Boston Globe – An amazing feat of responsive web design
  • 10K Apart – From the very smart people at An Event Apart
  • AR Web Design – My own website

So which is the better option?

Well actually, both options have their advantages. A better question is “Which option is right for me?”

There are three things you need to consider when deciding: context, content and of course your current situation.

Context for Responsive Web Design

If your website is responsive, it will serve the same content to both small and large screens, the only thing that changes is the formatting. If you have a separate mobile website however, you can (if you like) serve completely different content to a mobile user.

To decide whether or not to show different content to mobile users, we need to consider their context.

For example, consider if you were to access our website from your computer at home. It’s likely that your goal is to see how we stack up against other web companies, so you’ll probably check out some of our free tools, view our portfolio and maybe read about our methodology.

Mobile

If you’re accessing our website from a mobile however, it’s likely you have different goals in mind. Maybe you’re on your way to our office and need to double check our address or call to tell us you’re running late.

So in our case it might make sense to serve different content (specifically, contact information) to mobile users. It might be different for your website though, have a think about what you can assume (if anything) about a user accessing your website via their mobile, and whether that means you should serve different content to mobile vs desktop users.

Be aware though that mobile users aren’t always “mobile”. More and more people are using their mobiles to access the internet from home while watching TV. There are still plenty of people who’s sole internet connected device is their phone. And as phones get better, it will become more and more difficult to predict a mobile user’s intentions.

Content

A big consideration when developing a website for mobile devices is speed. Mobile users are often using slower or weaker internet signals than desktops, and mobile browsers are still a bit slower than their desktop counterparts. This means it’s important that we don’t include anything unnecessary, especially if it’s likely to impact on the load time.

One of the disadvantages of responsive web design is that while you can easily tell design elements not to display on mobile devices.  In most cases it doesn’t stop them from being downloaded and taking up bandwidth. To some extent you can get around this by serving mobile content by default, then only downloading desktop assets for larger displays, but the more images, slideshows, videos and general interactivity your site has, the harder it’s going to be to stop it from downloading on mobiles. In this case, you might be better off choosing to have a separate mobile site developed.

Your Current Situation

The last thing to consider when making your decision is your current situation. I.e. How satisfied are you with your current website? How’s your budget? How valuable are your mobile visitors (potentially)?

If you already have a website and want it to become responsive, chances are it’s going to need to be completely re-designed, so will likely be more expensive than developing a separate mobile version. Of course if you’re not happy with your current website, this may be a good thing.

If however you don’t already have a website (or you’re not happy with your existing website), taking the responsive approach may be cheaper than going with a separate mobile version, as a new website and separate mobile version would usually be thought of as separate projects.

Of course, while one option may be cheaper than the other, it doesn’t always mean that’s the path you should take. If your mobile visitors are potentially valuable, or if you get (or hope/expect to get) a lot of mobile traffic, you should probably spend more time considering context and content than budget.

In Short

Responsive web design is really cool, but has it’s disadvantages in some situations. If your mobile users want different content to your web users, or if your website is full of functionality and interactivity, you may be better off developing a separate mobile website. Otherwise, go responsive…

MARKETING METHODOLOGY

Genius Model - Bluewire Media v2

PS. When you're ready, here are 6 ways we help consultants & advisors grow:

1. Web Strategy Planning Template (PDF). Our flagship 1-page tool we co-created with David Meerman Scott. It’s been downloaded over 1 million times and featured on Forbes.

2. Read a free chapter from our book. Web Marketing That Works --- an Amazon #1 best seller.

3. Join the private group on Facebook. Access free training resources, and hang out with 2,300+ peers.

4. Discover your marketing score. Take the 40 point Marketing Scorecard (in < 6mins) and get a customised report.

5. DIY for $7. Get the Complete 50+ Script Library for connecting with people to winning clients.

6. Let's brainstorm how to fill your marketing funnel. DM the word "INTERESTED" via Messenger or book a 20 min slot to talk on Zoom.

 

  • About the Author
  • Latest Posts

About Angus Russell

  • Solving the Issue of Context in Responsive Web Design - Apr 27, 2013
  • How to make sure your website doesn’t work for your business - Apr 27, 2012

Share5
Share2
Pin
Tweet9
16 Shares
12 Comments
Web Strategy, Web Design
Mobile Websites, Responsive Web Design
 0 Shares
Tweet

Posted on Dec 8, 2011

Content Marketing Sales Funnel 3D Icon

Content Marketing Sales Funnel

Your content marketing sales funnel is all about getting people to know, like and trust you by nurturing them with the right information at the right time.

Download it now

← I’m married…how do I change my name on Facebook and LinkedIn? Tim Martin – All roads lead to your website →
  • Latest
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Fake negative comments Jun 23, 2022
  • 7 Offline Marketing Strategies That Your Online Brand Must Adopt Jun 17, 2022
  • How To Get Internet for Your Home in 3 Easy Steps Jun 13, 2022
  • My first keynote back Jun 2, 2022
  • How to Boost Your B2B Sales using Influencer Marketing May 5, 2022
  • Marketing experimentsMarketing Experiments: Email Content That Gets Clicked Apr 23, 2013
  • LinkedIn Marketing Strategy Infographic Nov 13, 2013
  • seo-secretsFishing for backlinks – Tips from SEO Secrets Oct 27, 2009
  • Your Ultimate Blog Checklist Jul 16, 2014
  • DanNorrisThe 5 Best Google Analytics Reports for Content Marketers Jan 8, 2014
  • Faux damaging feedback – Bluewire Media – Daily Business & Economy News and Information | Titan Business Consultants […] ← 7 Offline Advertising and marketing
  • Faux damaging feedback – Bluewire Media – Daily Business & Economy News and Information | Daily Business Digest […] ← 7 Offline Advertising and marketing
  • 7 Offline Marketing Strategies That Your Online Brand Must Adopt - applebusiness […] Resource website link […]
  • How to Boost Your B2B Sales using Influencer Marketing - PDL-10 […] Source link […]
  • Always-On Surges In B2B, Employee Influencers Build Trust, LinkedIn's New Captions, & Video Distribution Study - News As it Happens […] TopRank Marketing — How to Boost Your
#thebigwet Adsense blue sky factory cara drolshagen copy customer relationship management Dibgy Ioane Dogpile education websites expert interview garageband geo location Gmail Google Earth googleplex Instagram Internet jack dorsey Jason Fried Know your mojo LinkedIn London riots mike lieberman networx NSBS online advertising Outlook 2010 password photography RichardatDELL simon townsend social media. business subfolders Successful Blog success insights sunday mail socials sydney tips Toby Jenkins user testing VA web development Wikis wireframing zuckerberg

Archives

  • 2022 (15)
  • 2021 (20)
  • 2020 (94)
  • 2019 (132)
  • 2018 (31)
  • 2017 (60)
  • 2016 (131)
  • 2015 (176)
  • 2014 (122)
  • 2013 (99)
  • 2012 (73)
  • 2011 (93)
  • 2010 (152)
  • 2009 (135)
  • 2008 (1)
  • Back to Top
    • Home
    • Free Marketing Templates
    • Speaker
    • News
    • Events
    • Podcast
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Search
    • Bluewire Community
      • Free Marketing Templates
      • Amazon – Web Marketing That Works
      • Join our Faceook group
      • iTunes – Web Marketing That Works
      • Spotify – Web Marketing That Works
      • Bluewire Podcast
      • Recommended Reading
      • Online Tools
      • Student Centre Login
      • Subscribe to Bluewire News
      • Sitemap
    • Hire Adam Franklin to Speak
      • Social Media Speaker
      • Digital Marketing Speaker
      • Keynote Speaker
      • Marketing Speaker
      • LinkedIn Keynote Speaker
      • Harbour Space Uni Lecturer
      • Toby Jenkins
    • Adam Franklin – Awards Judge
      • Optus MyBusiness Awards
      • Real Estate Business (REB) Awards
      • Australian Broking Awards
      • Australian Accounting Awards
      • Women in Real Estate Awards
      • Better Business Summit Awards
      • Young Leaders In Finance Awards
    • Contributors To
      • The Australian
      • Sydney Morning Herald
      • Smart Company
      • Huffington Post
      • Convince & Convert
      • Hubspot
      • Problogger
      • Kochie’s Business Builders
      • Entrepreneur HQ
      • Dent /Key Person of Influence
      • Life Hacker
      • Quora
      • Medium
      • Elite Agent
    • Working with Bluewire
      • Hire Adam Franklin
      • As a Client
      • As an Affiliate
      • As an Event Attendee
      • As a Guest Blogger
      • As a Partner
      • Testimonials
    • Connect on Social Media
      • Adam Franklin on LinkedIn
      • Twitter
      • LinkedIn
      • Facebook
      • YouTube
      • Instagram
      • Pinterest
      • Slideshare
    • Disclosure
      • Disclosure & Terms and Conditions
      • GDPR Compliance & Privacy Policy
    Australia

    6/179 Baroona Road
    Paddington
    QLD 4064

    Copyright © 2022 All contents Creative Commons Licensed Bluewire Media Pty Ltd.